Decandling, or candle cutting, removes the whole spring shoot from a strong, refined black pine once its first flush has matured, so the tree grows a second flush of shorter shoots and shorter needles. Cut the weakest shoots first and the strongest last, leave longer stubs and fewer old needles on strong shoots, and pause feeding at the cut.

Which trees to cut, and which to leave

  • Cut a healthy, well-fed tree in refinement; Dupuich notes the job can, in some cases, strip up to 60 to 70% of the foliage.
  • Leave a weak, under-fed tree, or one repotted this year, and wait a year.
  • Leave a tree whose trunk must still thicken, or one with a sacrifice branch: cutting slows thickening.
  • Leave, or cut every other year, a tree in shade or in a cool, short summer, where Hagedorn finds the second flush erratic.
  • Never cut single-flush pines such as white or Scots pine; Bonsai Empire warns "It could be fatal to remove all their candles".

Stage and climate

Cut once the spring candles have extended and the first flush has matured, with enough warm season left for a second flush to harden. Dupuich's rule is to cut sooner where summers are cool and later where they are warm: the start of summer in a cool climate, early summer in a mild climate, early to midsummer in a warm one and midsummer in a hot one. Too early gives long needles; too late gives little or no summer growth, only buds that open next spring. Large trees go earlier and small ones later, so needle length stays in scale. In Canberra, in the southern hemisphere, growers warn "if you haven't finished decandling by Christmas you might be too late".

How to cut, weakest first

  1. Sort the candles by length: the long, strong ones usually sit at the top and the outer tips.
  2. Cut the weak shoots first, then the medium and strong ones: growers space these stages 10 to 14 days apart.
  3. We recommend a shorter plan: cut the weak shoots, the very smallest included, a week or so ahead of the strong ones; growers differ on cutting the smallest at all.
  4. Shoots cut first get the most time to regrow, so weak areas close the gap; cutting strong ones first would widen it.

Stub length and needles

Cut square, close to the base, and leave a little of this year's shoot, because the new buds sprout from that tissue; do not cut the surrounding needles. Dupuich grades the stub by strength: about twice the shoot's diameter on strong shoots (1/4 to 1/2 in), about once on medium ones (1/8 to 1/4 in) and about half on weak ones (1/16 to 1/8 in). Hagedorn and Peter Tea agree that a longer stub slows the summer shoots. Then thin the old needles: Dupuich leaves 3 to 7 pairs on strong shoots, 5 to 9 on medium and 7 to 12 on weak, and leaves shoots with only 1 to 3 pairs alone.

Line drawing: a spring candle with a dashed cut line just above its base, and three cut shoots in a grid, labelled weak, medium and strong, with stubs of half, one and two shoot widths and fewer needle pairs on the stronger shoots First: a spring candle on last year's shoot, with a cut line just above the candle's base. Then three cut shoots. The weak shoot is cut first, with a stub half the shoot's width and the most needle pairs left. The medium shoot is cut about ten days later, with a stub one shoot width long. The strong shoot is cut last, with a stub two shoot widths long and the fewest needle pairs. The removed candles are shown as dashed outlines. Before the cut once the first flush matures springcandle cut nearthe base last year's shoot and old needle pairs Weak cut first stub ½ × width candleremoved keep 7 to 12 pairs of old needles Medium about 10 days later stub 1 × width keep 5 to 9 pairs of old needles Strong cut last stub 2 × width keep 3 to 7 pairs of old needles
Where to cut, and what to leave. Weak shoots are cut first with a short stub and the most needles; strong shoots last with the longest stub and the fewest. Our drawing, from Dupuich's figures; needle pairs are drawn as a sample within each range, and the shoots at the same width for comparison. Drawing: Bonsai – The Living Collection.

Feeding before and after

Feed heavily from when the roots wake in spring until the cut, so the tree has the strength for a second flush. Stop at the cut so the new needles stay short; growers differ on when to restart, and we recommend waiting until the second flush has hardened. Keep heavy rain off the second flush, as extra water lengthens needles.

What happens next

New buds show within 7 to 12 days, and the summer shoots are growing well by about five weeks. A medium shoot usually gives two summer shoots, and a strong one three to five or more. In autumn each cluster is cut down to two, though growers differ on which two (see the black pine guide).

Spring candle breaking is a different technique

In spring, before the needles open, an over-strong candle can be broken partway: that shoot weakens, the others strengthen, and no second flush follows. We recommend letting spring candles grow and relying on the summer cut, though growers differ.

Where growers differ

The very smallest candles. Our recommendation, where growers differ: cut them too, first, about a week ahead of the strong ones; Hagedorn, in one post, also cuts the small ones. Others differ: Hagedorn in another post, and the Buffalo Bonsai Society, leave them alone.

Staged or all in one day. Growers differ: Peter Tea, the Buffalo Bonsai Society and Walston stage the cut, as we recommend, while Dupuich also cuts in one day when vigour is fairly even, balancing with stubs and needle counts.

Leaving a stub at all. Growers differ: Eastern Leaf and Daiju-en cut at the very base, with no stub, though Daiju-en says a stub only delays and shortens the second flush.

The last feed before cutting. Growers differ, with no recommended way: Mirai gives the last feed a month before, while Dupuich feeds up to the cut.

When feeding restarts. Our recommendation, where growers differ: once the second flush has hardened, as Bonsai Empire advises. Others restart after four weeks, or "about a month or two later" (Dupuich), after 4 to 6 weeks (Hagedorn) or when the second buds push (Buffalo Bonsai Society); Mirai, in Oregon's mild summers, does not feed "from mid-July through August".

A warm climate's date. Growers differ, with no recommended way: Dupuich places Los Angeles in his warm-climate window, while Hagedorn puts it "closer to July 4th".

Sources